Several years’ ago, the stars aligned for Matthew Pennington. He found a solid crew of like-minded food folk, happened upon the perfect setting for a restaurant, began growing his own veg, created beautiful dishes for a full restaurant day after day, perfected a legendary toffee apple cake, made cider; made it. A best-selling cookbook, a much-lauded vermouth, a loyal following, London pop-ups and several industry accolades later, The Ethicurean was about to open a second site on a vineyard in Cornwall when Co-vid hit. I got in touch with Matthew during lockdown to find out how things were going at his end and was saddened to hear that it was very much touch and go for the business he had put his heart and soul into over the years. Despite going through the mill, as many a restauranteur has over the past few months, The Ethicurean has ridden the wave of uncertainty all the way to the shore. This is due in no small part to the immense hard work, ingenuity and indefatigable drive of Matthew and his team.
I’m delighted that Matthew has kindly spared some rare time out from his ridiculously busy schedule to chat to me candidly about his experience of lockdown from a small business-owner’s perspective. Matthew’s passion for food ethics and how this feeds into our enjoyment of what we choose to eat, is underscored by his conviction that good things come from being true to yourself. One of the most admirable things about this self-taught chef is his resilience in the face of adversity. This comes, in part, from his being a rather charming combination of geek and philosopher. I can’t help thinking, however, that that’s actually pretty much what you need to make it in this industry; particularly during such uncertain times. Matthew is also a superlatively inquisitive and creative Renaissance man who can turn his hand to just about anything (including boat building and some pretty bangin’ DJ sets). We covered a lot of ground in our chat: from foraging, to immune boosting ferments, to heroic planet-saving worms but, regrettably, I still didn’t manage to get the recipe for his toffee apple cake. This is probably for the best because Hels’ Kitchen would never make anything else ever again were I to discover the secret; besides, it gives me the perfect excuse to keep on returning to this beautiful walled garden in the Mendips where I know there will always be a slice waiting and a warm welcome from an old friend.

It takes a certain kind of person to set-up a restaurant and make a success of it. Why did you enter this industry, and what were you doing beforehand?
Oddly enough I’m not even sure there was ever a plan to have a restaurant. I’ve always adored the outdoors and grew-up eager to be lost in nature at any opportunity. In my formative years I joined the scouts and was very fortunate to have been treated to a forest schooling that would be rare in this age. On our camping trips in North Wales, we learned how to be observant of the environment that cradles us, to discern patterns in nature, make a shelter and relish the long dark nights. We also learned how to cook from foraged foods on gathered firewood. We entrapped rabbits and cooked them ‘Sunday lunch style’ with all the trimmings. Each ingredient was tenderly braised in cooperatively built, wood-fired mud ovens, that we’d made by the riverside in the days prior. Those outings made me look at nature in the light it deserves and see that human kindness and knowledge is to be shared. I owe our old forest leaders sincere gratitude for that. That thread of yearning to understand nature and share its bounty never abated.
In my early adulthood, however, I found myself taking temp work in a factory – a place completely contradictory to the natural world I felt so in tune with. I was bussed to a different location on a random food production line every night for many long months and I learned that the cereal bars that fell off the mechanised production line were valueless. I took my wage and diligently swept up and shovelled countless bin-fulls of bars but I didn’t last long there. I couldn’t eat the food we were producing without it causing me inherent mistrust.
So, after too many years of being stuck in work I didn’t necessarily enjoy just to earn a crust, I decided instead to attempt to quench a passion, one that I hadn’t quite put my finger on but knew was within. My early era influence undoubtedly came to the fore when it came to my finding what it was that would make my brain smile. Trying to think theoretically about what influenced me and what I cared for in life, I found that I kept coming back to a couple of phrases: the Taoist “For all you need to know about life, look at water“; and Einstein’s “Look deep into nature, and then you will understand everything better“. Taking time for critical reflection, I found myself thinking back to childhood times when I felt most care-free, when the path of least resistance got me where I wanted and where patience rewarded natural achievement. I remembered building ovens, foraging with friends and sharing our spoils.
I took employment in a delicatessen and that’s where it truly began. I relished the opportunity to taste every single ingredient I could. Thus it happened that the realisation of how special food can be knocked on the door of my olfactory nerve. I could see that food producers on our soils were going to have a punt at rivalling long-established traditional European producers. The UK was starting to awaken from its post-war, bland and beige mentality. I didn’t know it yet, but this was to lead me to own a restaurant in a Victorian walled garden.
What led you to create The Ethicurean?
When you lavish time and consideration into food craft, you can create the incredible. I wanted to embark on a project of my own that supported the the UK food scene. With the only money I’ve ever managed to save, I set-up a stall at various burgeoning farmers markets. The aim – a closed-loop and sustainable food offer. We would buy from producers at the markets we attended and home-cook what we purchased to take to the next market. Two years of appearing in remote West-Country towns, tempting folk to try everything we had made was a hand to mouth and unrelenting existence. We spent many nights cooking until 3am and would be out on the road again at six, bleary-eyed. The producers I met along the way I could see were grafting just the same. Those farmers, growers and artisans had managed to do it; they were producing ingredients and crafted foods to be proud of far beyond their modest stalls. They inspired me. I wanted to support their movement and I still count many as close friends a decade later.
While I had been working on deli counters, my brother, Iain (one of the original founders of The Ethicurean), had travelled and worked in cocktail bars. We were both ideally positioned to be spoiled by the world of exquisite artisan food craft and, of course, its accompanying drink culture. That spilt over into seeking food adventures where the culinary destination was the reason for the trip: the bar snack Pintxos of the Basque region in Spain; the charred pork, annatto and pineapple Taco al Pastor of a travelling street vendor in late-night Mexico City; or an unforgettably, fat-layered, rich, nourishing reindeer broth that denied the minus twenty-five degree cold of northern Norway its aim. We took several trips to Scandinavia in fact, to eat at restaurants that align with nature (like Ekstetd and the now sadly wrapped-up Fäviken). We didn’t shy away from spending every penny for the culinary pursuit.

Pop-up times 
Out on a forage
Obviously we learned a great deal on our travels but something in particular spoke to me about every one of these experiences: food is enjoyment. Cherish every possible moment around it. Share it with your dearest, friends, kin and even strangers, because there’s only so many times we will get to do that. Food, grown, tended and cooked from its direct landscape also tastes unique to that place. Moments of sheer deliciousness arise because of this. Everything was aligning to build the idea that became The Ethicurean.
And on that note, what lies at the heart of the Ethicurean?
There are common grounds between the health of nature, the microbiome of soil, the culture of the people that work upon it, the purity of the food they produce and the quality of what we eat. Careful consideration to all, in turn, nourishes our guts and improves our health and direct mental well-being.
The Ethicurean strives to balance these grounds. Hopefully, no one notices our hyperbole when they visit (…!) but, rather, just enjoys The Ethicurean experience: slowing down, taking in the surroundings and having moments to consider nature. We have no doubt they will enjoy our food and libations – that’s the part we specialise in. We hope that inspiration to raise the continuum naturally follows for our guests; be that as simple as spending more time walking in search of wild food, growing their own food or looking at the fascinating re-wilding movement currently happening across the UK.
You once said to me, if you want to lose a lot of money really quickly, open a restaurant. The Ethicurean has gone from strength to strength. What is the secret to its success (apart from the toffee apple cake that I (and many others) make a special trip for)?
Yeah, it’s a complex puzzle, the ol’ restauranteering. The past twenty years have certainly seen a race to the bottom for the majority of UK restaurants. Operating margins were historically around 15% annually near the turn of the millennium. Now, an industry-wide survey shows it closer to 3-4% for those that manage to break into profit. Most of us are competing with international corporate giants that use complicated accountancy to offset costs and lessen their tax burden. Those same outfits use low welfare ingredients to increase margin, meaning that customer expectation on price or value of food has shifted. It’s not working in favour of independent restaurants; even those that get past the most challenging first three years (during which most will go out of business). I’ll admit that even six years into this project, we almost went the same route and faced near financial collapse one or two winters. Nothing other than sheer determination, personal financial sacrifice and choosing not to dilute our principles ensured we made it through. We tightened every business aspect, learned lessons from our shortcomings and continued to vocalise our message.
Blessed by continued support from guests who felt our message on sustainability resonated with them, it turned out that remaining tight-pursed to our motives was where success lay.

If you want to get ahead, get a hat 
TOFFEE APPLE CAKE! (of dreams)
Pre-pandemic, we were finally in profit! We were proudly paying our growing team, as we always had, over the living wage and, for the first time, my brother and I too. F***-me! Wowsers. We could never have expected that! Our success was reliant on our principals: if we protect nature, farm microbes for the gut and the soil, it can provide for us. We’ve always been transparent and we’ve never driven supplier prices down. We have also always looked after our team – staunchly paying above minimum wage, focussing on mental health, taking breaks and spending time in nature. These feel like the successes to us.
[more… turn the page]

