Hot Cross Buns

I make these religiously (pun fully intended) every Easter, without fail.  The main reason I make these, apart from the fact that a toasted bun spread with butter truly is a thing of beauty but the other reason I make them is that the aroma of spiced buns cooking is a lovely thing to fill the house with (as is the aroma of a spiced bun toasting in the morning).  The spices are a pretty winning combo – cinnamon, mixed spice, ginger and allspice but it’s the addition of ground cloves that is key.  This guy really makes the spices sing.

I’m also a huge fan of a currant bun.  I’m less down with raisins and sultanas – for me, currants are where it’s at.  That being said, I do add sultanas here for balance.

In all the years I’ve been making these (which is a fair few) I’ve never mastered the art of piping the crosses on the top – the weird little flour/water paste is too sticky to work with efficiently/neatly so instead I’ve developed a somewhat labourious method of rolling out little sausages of paste instead and placing them on top of the buns.  Seems to work, it’s just a pain in the a*se and a part of the process that I don’t wholly enjoy it has to be said – by that point, I just want a damn bun!  But, like most things, it’s all worth it in the end.

Finally, my recipe uses bread flour as opposed to plain – I prefer the deeper flavour/and slightly richer texture.  If you don’t get the rising/proving right then this can result in pretty dense buns nail it and you get lovely fluffy ones that toast amazingly and soak-up all that lovely salted butter when it melts into them.

 

******************

Foraged buns…  should you fancy experimenting:

Around Eastertime my friend, John Rensten of Forage London, sent me some foraged bits to kick-off our collaboration – he forages, I bake.  So I’m updating this recipe as below with my take on a version using foraged UK spices… this is from my Instagram:

“To be honest, when @foragelondon gave me the foraged bits, I tasted the birch syrup – lovely – lots of sweet depth; I nibbled a dried magnolia leaf – gingery vibe tending towards bitter; then I looked at the wood avens… it looked like something an owl had puked-up. But, if you nibble the woody strands it tastes akin to clove. So, in keeping with the season, I decided to make more hot cross buns but this time – with ground/up foraged spices and birch syrup instead of sugar.

I decided not to add anything else as I wanted to see what these ingredients would do. As cautioned by John, the magnolia and wood avens are “like” ginger and clove but more bitter. That being said, the birch syrup has rich depth which complements the sweetness of the currants. I nibbled currants with ground-up spices laced with birch syrup to get the combo right and ensure I didn’t end up with bitter buns. The only addition I made was the zest of half a lemon – just to bring it all together, and give it a lift. And here they are. As you can see (compare and contrast with the previous post of “normal” buns) they are lighter. They are also lighter in flavour and aroma – so the kitchen wasn’t filled with heady spices but with a gentle floral note with a gingery lift and delicate yet enticing warmth from the wood avens and the birch. Their lightness and lifted notes from these foraged spices remind me of saffron buns as they sit on the not overly sweet side of the spectrum. As such, they have a sort of medieval vibe to them, which I rather like as it felt a bit medieval to be grinding-up leaves and stems (in a cool way ?).

My basic recipe is the same as the one on my website except as follows:

– replace the sugar… 2 tblsp birch syrup
– replace all spices … just 1 heaped tsp ground magnolia and 1/2 tsp ground wood avens stems
– add zest of 1/2 lemon
– glaze with slightly diluted birch syrup.”

 

Makes: c. 9 buns

Takes: brace yourself, it takes a bit of time… and it’s good to make sure you have a little timetable (eg I often forget I have to warm the milk and let it cool – that kind of thing can be a bit annoying timetable-wise).  1 hour + 10 mins + 15 mins + 2 hours + 10 mins + 45 mins (during which proving you can make your little crosses)

Bakes: c. 20 mins.  pre-heat the oven to 180C (GM4) and line a baking tray with non-stick parchment

 

Ingredients

  • 200g currants
  • 50g sultanas
  • 300g strong white bread flour
  • 150g wholemeal bread flour (if you want a lighter bun then just roll with all strong white flour so add another 150g of that to the 300g instead of wholemeal)
  • 7g fast action dried yeast (i.e. 1 sachet)
  • 50g caster sugar
  • 280g milk
  • 10g salt flakes (crushed)
  • 50g butter (room temperature)
  • 1 large egg
  • 2 tsp cinnamon
  • 1 tsp mixed spice
  • 1 tsp ground ginger
  • 1/2 tsp ground cloves
  • 1/2 tsp allspice

For the crosses

  • 50g plain flour
  • pinch of baking powder
  • 1/2 tsp vegetable oil
  • 50g cold water

For the glaze

  • 2 tblsp caster sugar
  • 2 tblsp cold water

 

Method

First thing is the milk. Heat this to boiling then cool to room temperature (probably c. 15 mins).  It’s important that the milk is cooled – you don’t want to add hot milk to the yeast.

Next attend to the fruit – pop the currants and sultanas in a bowl and cover them with boiled water.  Leave them to plump up for c. 1 hour (stirring occasionally).

Next combine the flours in a large mixing bowl and make a well in the centre.  Put the yeast and sugar into this then pour in the cooled milk.  Flick a little flour over the top of the liquid to cover it.  Then cover with cling film and leave to rest for 1 hour (so your currants etc will be soaking at the same time).  After an hour it should be a little foamy and bubbly on top. If it isn’t, have a look a little bit beneath the surface.  If there’s nothing going on at all then the best thing to do is to start again but it should be fine!

Next, sprinkle the salt around the edge of the flour then add the butter, egg and spices to the well.  Mix all of this in together until you have a rough dough then pop it out onto a clean worktop – try to resist the urge to dollop loads of flour down – you shouldn’t need it.  Knead for c. 8-10 mins until you have a nice firm dough.  Towards the end of the kneading time, add your fruit, working it gently into the dough (there will be the odd escapee currant, most likely).  Pop this back into the bowl, cover with cling film and leave in a warm place to rise for a good 2 hours at least (until doubled in size) – may take a bit longer than 2 hours.  Don’t skimp on the doubling though.

After 2 hours you should have a dough that’s doubled in size.  Remove from the bowl and divide it into 9 equal portions. You will probably need to add a ittle flour to your hands before you work the dough further.  Form each portion into ball by flattening them out slightly and pulling the edges into the centre, working your way around the dough, then turn the ball over and drag it slightly across the worktop until it goes taut on top.  Place this dough ball onto the baking tray and repeat with the other 8 buns.  Cover them with cling film and return them to the warm spot to prove for a good 45 mins. My preference is to space them apart on the sheet as opposed to baking them all up in each others’ grills but you can do that if you prefer.

While they are proving, make the crosses.  Basically mix all the ingredients together.  If you prefer/are able (I’ve never managed it) you can use a piping bag to pipe these across the buns.  I find this mix really odd to work with so instead, I add a little more flour to it, I flour my hands and I set about making little strings with the paste.  I line them up then when the buns are ready to go into the oven, I just lay them across each one, tucking them underneath.  I then tweak them so they are neat.  It’s a bit laborious but it works and, actually, I quite like those bits a bit more crunchy.

When the buns have their crosses, pop them into the oven to bake, spritzing a little water in before you put them in.  You want a nice rise and a nice burnished brown top to each one but you don’t want much colour (if any) on the crosses – these should still be white(ish).

While they are cooking, pop the sugar and water into a pan over a gentle heat until the sugar has melted.  As soon as the buns come out of the oven, brush each one with the glaze then transfer them to a cooling rack.

They are amazing hot off the press but, for me, they are at their finest toasted (this means that you don’t have to eat them all fresh on the same day either).  They make a particularly fine breakfast (or accompaniment to an afternoon teabreak).  They will also freeze well. I had some last year that I’d made the previous year and they were bomber.

Comments

Hit me up with any variations you've got for these ingredients.

Leave a Comment